For the critique challenge assigment in design aesthetic course, i have to make an aesthetic evaluation upon animation video. The choosen animation is Hikayat Sang Kancil dan Monyet and Hikayat Sang Kancil dan Buaya. The criterion has been set based on relativism. The criteria are i.e :
1. Audience should be able to remember half of the video after a long time as compared to Hikayat Sang
Kancil dan Buaya.
2. Audience should be able to laught out immediately as compared to Hikayat Sang Kancil dan Buaya.
3. Audience should be able to finish watching the animation from the beginning to the end voluntarily as
compared to Hikayat Sang Kancil dan Monyet.
4. Audience should be able to feel nostalgic to the extent that they remeber their old story as compared to
Hikayat Sang Kancil dan Buaya.
I say this because this animation to give a lesson to all society. Besides that, the advice of friends must be received by faith that we act and dont be stubborn. These lessons will be remembered by the society, especially poor children. The second critique why i say that because the animation of Hikayat Sang Kancil dan Monyet is funny better than Hikayat Sang Kancil dan Buaya. The part was very funny that audience can see is when the monkey eat chillies. This monkey feel so hot and run away.
The third critique why i say that because the animation of Hikayat Sang Kancil dan buaya is can give audience blur and dont know what to happen at crocodile and mousedeer. The mousedeer is very clever to manage the crocodile that will eat him. It is very dangerous for mousedeer but the crocodile have been cheat of mousedeer. Last critique that i say that because most people cannot accept the others advantages. So, this lessons must be happen to sum of people.
I disagree with yellowflash4.blogspot.com say when audiens should be annoyed with the manner of the monkey instantly when he disturb the turtoise and the mousedeer. This is because monkey have his own right to make a discussion. So, audience should be understand that the monkey was hunger and neeed some food to life. I also was disagree with his opinion when he say audiens should be touched with the friendship between the character instantly after watching the animation. If for me, this relationship is normal and should not touched by audience. Mousedeer should be friend with monkey because the size body monkey like same with mousedeer. Not like turtoise, his size body was smaller than mousedeer. Turtoise should be friend with small animal like him.
No comments:
Post a Comment